News : Bisbee schools hope to lure teachers with bonus : Sierra Vista, AZ
Home News Opinion Sports Community Blogs Lifestyle Classifieds Entertainment Archives About Us

Today's Weather


Weather Magnet

Bisbee schools hope to lure teachers with bonus

By Katie Evans
Herald/Review
Published/Last Modified on Wednesday, Nov 26, 2008 - 05:20:11 am MST

SIERRA VISTA — With seven vacant teaching positions and a shortage of teachers nationwide, the Bisbee school district is looking for more innovative ways to recruit.

As part of this, during a special meeting held Monday night, the school board voted 3-1, with Luche Giacomino dissenting, to approve a teacher recruitment bonus for hard-to-fill teaching positions.

The bonus will be a $500-per-month housing subsidy for teachers who live in Bisbee, said Superintendent Gail Covington McBride. It will last for one year.


“This might give them a leg up,” Covington McBride said of potential new teachers who might be interested in making the move to Bisbee for a new job, but are possibly deterred by “the economy the way it is, and the housing situation and the challenges of moving.”

Hard-to-fill positions, for school districts in general, include math, science and special education, the superintendent said.

“But then there can be a position that’s hard to fill because it’s a specialty area,” Covington McBride said. “(Such as) band, there may not be a lot of band teachers.

“English language development teachers are hard-to-fill positions.”

On a district level, Covington McBride said their sixth-grade teacher positions would be considered hard-to-fill because “they were open last spring and we weren’t able to fill them.”

As far as being available to afford to provide the bonuses, Covington McBride said “there is money available in some of our title money that is set aside for specifically recruiting highly-qualified teachers.”

In addition to that, she said money will be used from the maintenance and operation budget.

By doing the bonus on a month-to-month basis though, versus giving a teacher a signing bonus, Covington McBride said the district won’t be in a position to lose money.

“They receive the subsidy once a month, so if the teacher decided this wasn’t for them and broke the contract, the district wouldn’t be in the position of trying to get it back,” she said. “When you give a signing bonus, if the person leaves, you are really left with very little recourse to get it back.”

Covington McBride said she has plans at a future board meeting to bring the current teacher salary schedule forward for review.

With other rural school districts having trouble filling positions, Covington McBride felt it was important to find incentives to bring teachers to Bisbee.

“The data that we were just looking at … between Douglas and Tombstone there were 47 positions that had to be filled this year,” she said. “If you take our seven and the 47 together, there were over 50 positions that had to be filled.

“So we’re in a very competitive arena bringing teachers to our rural schools.”

Giacomino said in a phone interview Tuesday that she voted against the proposal because she felt it was unfair to teachers who have been in the district for years.

“Starting teacher’s salary is around $27,000,” she explained. “OK, you give them $500 for the first year, that’s $6,000.”

She said that would mean, while “we have people who have been around for years who are making $27,000,” new teachers coming in would essentially be making about $33,000.

“We need to recruit teachers, yes, but we’ve got good, qualified teachers over there now who wouldn’t be making that much money,” she said. “And I don’t think it’s fair to them, I think they should be making that $500 before new teachers do.”

In other recruiting efforts, Covington McBride said some administrators will go to Madison, Wis., for a teacher recruiting fair — the only winter recruiting fair. To help make the area more appealing, the superintendent said the district has been working with some local real estate agents to develop materials to give potential recruits an idea of the rental and housing market in the area, as well as general information about Bisbee.

“We really want at this recruiting fair to let teachers know where Bisbee is,” Covington McBride said. “We’re really trying to get people to know that this is a great place to live and work.”

Herald/Review reporter Katie Evans can be reached at 515-4611 or by e-mail at katie.evans@svherald.com.

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments appear once they are approved. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   





    Clive Mutschler wrote on Dec 1, 2008 11:49 AM:

    " A friend of mine passed along this Bisbee teacher article because 1. I lived there for about a year back in '75-'76. and 2. I am now a retired schoolteacher. When I see salary's as low as 27K it leads me to think that yes, there are still places that regard teaching as low on the totem pole. I don't care how "dedicated" a person might be, you must be kidding yourself if you think you can attract the "cream of the crop" with such an offer, think again and good luck to you, the kids deserve it. "

    To Bisberiffi wrote on Nov 28, 2008 2:22 PM:

    " Did you stop to think most of those at MVD and DOC are getting paid more than 27K without a Degree? Most of those workers go through extensive traning for a job that should require one... These Teachers spend an extra 4 years to obtain a degree and get nothing for it..
    This just dosen't seem fair to me "

    fed up wrote on Nov 27, 2008 8:19 PM:

    " Its about time people started to realize the situation in Bisbee. $27,000 barely pays the student loan payments. Whats going to happen when the teachers who have been with the district for many years retire in the next few years, (I'm counting about 6 off the top of my head. This area offers very little for recent graduates, and they can't afford what there is on $27,000 a year. The sad thing is that its not enough to raise a family on. "

    Funny wrote on Nov 26, 2008 9:42 PM:

    " Now why would a person move to Arizona to teach in the k12? After paying for a bachelor degree or better, a teacher's license, moving expenses, etc... all for 27k a year! Get real. The economy is pathetic but these salaries were a joke long before the stocks headed South. "

    Bisberiffic wrote on Nov 26, 2008 8:03 PM:

    " Luche - are you kidding -- $27,000?? You can't get prison guards or MVD workers for that. If you care about having children in Bisbee and making it a real city, you've got to do better. Otherwise, let's skip the teachers altogether and hire probation officers. "

    CGS wrote on Nov 26, 2008 7:06 PM:

    " To be a good teacher one has to look outside the box. It's not the money the teachers love, but the children and their thirst for knowledge. A salary of $27,000 is not a living wage in this area, especially in Old Bisbee where the houses still sell for far too high than they are really worth. I do have the highest respect for BUSD, its staff and facultiy. The hardest part is dealing with the parents who don't teach their kids the importance of an education and to respect their teachers. "

    A-parent wrote on Nov 26, 2008 2:47 PM:

    " my wife worked for the Bisbee Schools, and left because she could not get more than 8 hrs a week and the school system paid 2 people in her department to just sit and confound things for everyone else. Hope is on the way, sierra vista school system in retaliation of the defeat of the override, are going to let teachers go. These teachers will need work for a year. "

    Old Marine wrote on Nov 26, 2008 1:21 PM:

    " Sounds good to me. Looks like they have to post an extra attraction to draw qualified teachers into filling the open positions. "

    Just me wrote on Nov 26, 2008 12:43 PM:

    " I do not think that a housing bonus is the answer. Bisbee school system is losing ground and part of that has to do with the students and their lack of respect and ethics. I have a child in that school system and it is horribly lacking. If there was any other option for his education I would be tranferring him in a heart beat. "

    desert bat wrote on Nov 26, 2008 11:46 AM:

    " At $27,000 a year, Bisbee is not a great place to work as a teacher. After the first year of subsidy, whomever is recruited will leave. Where is the education continuity in that? Meanwhile, the teachers making under $33,000 with no subsidy will be rightfully upset. This is a "Good Job, Brownie" kind of deal. Ms. Giacomino was right to not sign onto this. Still, where is the discussion on figuring out how to pay all the teachers a decent wage? There's an "innovative way to recruit." "

    brian wrote on Nov 26, 2008 9:12 AM:

    " a tough nut to crack. how do you convince teachers that southern AZ is the right place to be? Bonuses may be a viable option, but it takes a special type of individual to appreciate this area enough to live here, or so I've been told by lifelong residents. good luck. "

    James W. Giacomino wrote on Nov 26, 2008 8:29 AM:

    " I also want to know if the money is being used out of the maintenance fund then what is the district going to do if something breaks? Take it out of the salary of the teachers? Also, Just because they are highly qualified does not mean they should get extra money.. All teachers in BUSD are or are becoming highly qualified! Give it to them ALL! "

    James W. Giacomino wrote on Nov 26, 2008 8:22 AM:

    " This is a real slap in the face to veteran teachers that have dedicated their lives to this district. If the recruits can get this #500 extra dollars then why can't everyone else.. They have families too, they have bills to pay and they are living in the same economic turmoil..And what about the hostility that will be created within the district? Did anyone think of that? Kudos to Grandma Luche! "

Multimedia



In Tomorrow's Herald


START THE SEASON: Look for a special section with craft ideas, gift ideas and local residents sharing holiday memories.

Subscribe Today!

Photo Galleries

Contact Us


Staff Directory

Advertisement



Reader Poll



Calendar

Upcoming Events: