Opinion : POINT-COUNTERPOINT: Why Giffords should be re-elected : Sierra Vista, AZ

Today's Weather


Click for Sierra Vista, Arizona Forecast


POINT-COUNTERPOINT: Why Giffords should be re-elected


Published/Last Modified on Sunday, Oct 12, 2008 - 05:21:29 am MST

Commentary by Bob Bland
Special to the Herald/Review

Gabrielle Giffords was no stranger to Cochise County when she first ran for Congress two years ago, and throughout her first term, she’s fulfilled her promises to this area by standing up for us in Washington and fighting for common-sense solutions. She has kept an office in Sierra Vista and has been to Cochise County 22 times since taking office.

Giffords’ office in Sierra Vista has handled 820 cases for constituents and engaged in more than 23,000 phone calls, e-mails and letters with Cochise County residents.

Two weeks ago, Giffords joined Barack Obama and John McCain in voting for a much-needed emergency financial rescue bill after the unrestrained greed of Wall Street and eight years of Republican control combined to cost us 750,000 jobs and bring our economy to the brink of depression.



Despite major reservations about parts of the bill, Giffords said that not voting would irresponsibly risk economic collapse, threatening retirement accounts, jobs, banks and the survival of small businesses. One local bank executive told Giffords he was forced to stop lending for mortgages. Several business owners told her they could not get credit to meet payroll. Older citizens were terrified as they watched their retirement accounts disappear.

After opposing one flawed proposal, she supported a much-improved bill that not only addressed these concerns but also promoted policies she had been seeking: protected taxpayers from the Alternative Minimum Tax; increased the number of families qualifying for the child tax credit; extended tax deductions for state and local sales and property taxes; and increased FDIC insurance to $250,000.

“Congress has more work to do to fix this problem and the underlying regulatory problems that contributed to this mess,” she said.  “I will fight for strict oversight of how the rescue plan is administered … so that taxpayers will ultimately get a return on their money. This is the first of many votes that we will cast to restore fiscal discipline and regulation to the financial markets.”

Giffords will help ensure a secure retirement for hardworking families. Individuals, employers and government must all play a role. She will work for measures to preserve and protect existing public and private pension plans.

Giffords has pledged she will never subject Social Security to the risks of the stock market, while her opponent wants more study of privatization. Giffords is a tough and effective congresswoman who makes standing up for Southern Arizona her first priority. She’s an independent voice and an accessible representative, listening to her constituents and getting the job done.

Giffords has sought input from teachers, parents and business leaders in public hearings around the district and is fighting for reforms that will improve student learning, close achievement gaps, reduce class size and ensure that every child is taught by a highly qualified teacher. She has co-sponsored legislation that would give scholarships to college students studying to be math and science teachers, reduce interest rates on student loans and increase science standards in our nation’s schools.

Giffords has consistently voted to prevent cuts to Medicare and maintain reimbursement payments to doctors. She helped to override the president’s veto of the Medicare physician payment bill, protecting health care access for millions of seniors.

She also has introduced or co-sponsored bills to provide for public-private partnerships to speed new scientific discoveries into new medical treatments, increase breast cancer research, provide improved mental health care, reduce costs for prescriptions, and repeatedly voted to increase children’s health care funding.

Giffords works to transform our nation’s failing energy policy with a serious commitment to energy independence. She is determined to see America reach a goal of 20 percent renewable energy by 2020 and a reduced dependence on foreign oil. She proposed key elements in the comprehensive energy bill that helps end our nation’s dependence on foreign oil by opening limited new areas for drilling and advancing the use of clean, renewable sources of energy such as solar power. 

As the only member of Congress married to an active duty member of our military, Giffords knows firsthand about the sacrifices our veterans have made. A respected member of the House Armed Services Committee, she is a steadfast supporter of Fort Huachuca and Davis-Monthan. She has led efforts to support our veterans by modernizing the “GI Bill” with expanded educational benefits and voted to provide the largest funding increase in VA history, including $600 million in additional funds for mental health programs and traumatic brain injuries.

Understanding the challenges unique to military families, she authored the law that allows members of the military who serve in combat zones to qualify for the Earned Income Tax Credit.

For more information, visit www.giffordsforcongress.com.

BOB BLAND is chairman of the Cochise County Democratic Party. The party office is at 1010 E. Fry Blvd. For information, call 458-9467, or go online to www.cochisedemocrats.com.



Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments appear once they are approved. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   





    SVH EDITOR wrote on Oct 29, 2008 5:09 PM:

    " EDITOR'S NOTE: Per previously stated elections policy, comments are now closed." "

    John Fischer wrote on Oct 28, 2008 9:58 AM:

    " Hey Bland,
    Get your facts straight about the financial failure and the bailout. You dems remind me of the OJ jury... can't connect the dots because you won't look at the dots. Sick. "

    Hmmm wrote on Oct 28, 2008 9:50 AM:

    " DR I find it funny that you and a few other whack jobs call Congress the do nothing Congress and bring up the approval rating yet the repubicans are slated to loose more seats in the house and senate? What gives? The polls show America doesn't believe your line of junk. The polls show America is fed up people exactly like you and that is why repubicans are being voted out by the dozens. Next week you can bow at my feet when President Obama is elected. Perhaps I will let you wash my car too. "

    TO DR wrote on Oct 28, 2008 12:42 AM:

    " How do you expect Congress to do anything when bush vetoes everything they send him. He is not partisan. He is about his own agenda. At least with Obama in the WH things can get done. Also, if you really want to look at the numbers bush has received the lowest approval rating and will go down as the worst president in our history. The low Congress rating combined with the polls show that America is fed up with the republicans in Congress and not the dems. Why else are the repubicans loosing seats this fall? "

    Astronauts Military wrote on Oct 27, 2008 10:07 AM:

    " Where did you people get the idea that an Astronaut is not a member of the military? CAPTAIN Mark Kelly is a member of the US Navy and became an astronaut after serving on two tours in Desert Storm. Please get your facts straight before calling an astronaut not a member of the US Military. "

    BB wrote on Oct 27, 2008 10:06 AM:

    " I don't like Bee that much but Giffords advertising actually changed my mind. Her ads are completely dishonest and make you think she must think the public are a bunch of morons. The barbie doll cowgirl ad and the ad that spins her vote for the bail-out actually make me want to puke. People are not that stupid Gabby. 2 years in congress does not a swaggering leader make. "

    DR wrote on Oct 27, 2008 9:37 AM:

    " Remember the low approval of the do nothing congress ie: Democratic. Miss Nazi Pelosi is at fault, lots of blame to go around. "

    Marc wrote on Oct 27, 2008 8:59 AM:

    " Bob, it will make no difference who gets elected. our gas prices in Sierra Vista will not go down, we will have 1000's of winter visitors from out of state that do not pay Az taxes or register their cars here, so we don't get money there. If one party knew that another party was going to destroy our economy, and said nothing, pointed fingers, just to make themselves look good and ensure their candidate would get put into office, think about it. Are we proud? Is that American. "Ask what you can do for your country". JFK "

    To Jack wrote on Oct 27, 2008 12:38 AM:

    " Lay blame??? It was Secretary Paulson who said the bush administration made some mistakes that lead to the crises. We totally agree with him. He accepted blame and we agree. Thanks for your concern though. "

    Oh no wrote on Oct 26, 2008 11:49 AM:

    " After watching Bee with Bush I almost threw up. I don't trust a guy who works like that. Very sneeky... What is he trying to hide? Why did he allow the budget to go in the toilet? At least Rep Giffords has proven herself worthy to her constituents. I will vote for her this time. I like how she thinks and asks questions unlike know it all Bee. That man scares me. "

    Look Deeper wrote on Oct 26, 2008 11:32 AM:

    " A vote for Giffords is a vote for special interests. She was proud that she kept the West Gate open, did she stop to think why they had to close it? The guard force is being reduced now and over the next few years. There isn't the manpower to keep it open. So guards have been moved from strategically sensitive areas (on a publically open post) to serve a few folks out the back gate. Safety issues can be addressed with keys and MPs. Had she funded the mandate, then perhaps that would've been something. "

    Tim Bee 4 Congress wrote on Oct 25, 2008 9:19 PM:

    " We must drill here and Drill NOW. Alternatives too. Giffords supported the DO NOTHING drill off shore MORE than 50 miles bill and proudly sent it to her constituents via email newsletter. She didn't think we'd read it. She is a LOUSY representative, no back bone, just follow DO NOTHING Pelosi and the other democrats. Tim Bee 4 Congress "

    jack wrote on Oct 25, 2008 8:39 AM:

    " For Bob Bland to lay the blame of the current economic crisis on the Republicans flies in the face of facts. Intelligent readers will also recognize his 'spin' for what it is and discount in the entirety the rest of his half-truths about the suitability of Giffords. "

    To Paul wrote on Oct 24, 2008 11:58 PM:

    " Okay for starters: What tax increase are you talking about? There have been no tax increases in the last two years you silly little republican liar. Did you forget it was your beloved Saint McShame that introduced the ammnesty bill to Congress? Here is the website. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,156637,00.html
    http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=24369
    Please if you are a republican stop with the lies. You are hurting your party more than helping it. Do yourself a favor and embrace the truth for a change. "

    Paul Arnold wrote on Oct 24, 2008 10:24 PM:

    " Giffords voted for the largest tax increase in history. She voted for the "bailout." In over 3K years of government attempts to manipulate the free market not ONE HAS EVER WORKED! Every such attempt has always been a disaster. Remember, Pelosi say Giffords do! Obama with the help of congressional puppets like Giffords will not only ram through massive tax increase they will also expand welfare to buy votes. Giffords wants amnesty for 30M illegals. The Obama/Giffords plan is to grab our 401K plans and give us retired people some of our own money back. "

    Vote Republican for responsive Govt wrote on Oct 24, 2008 7:01 PM:

    " Top Recipients of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac
    Campaign Contributions, 1989-2008
    1. Dodd, Christopher J D-CT $133,900
    2. Kerry, John D-MA $111,000
    . Obama, Barack D-IL $105,849
    4. Clinton, Hillary D-NY $75,550
    Obama got $105,849 from Fannie Mae in less than 4 years; for the others it was over many years. HOW responsive will he be to investigating the source of the financial mess? Not at all because he benefitted from Fannie Mae. OBAMA: NOT responsive and irresponsible. "

    Vote Republican for responsive Govt wrote on Oct 24, 2008 6:22 PM:

    " Hmmm, Republicans are responsible and responsive. Look at the last 2 years with democrats in charge of Congress. The worst approval ratings ever. They were NEITHER. They were NOT doing the job we elected them to do: Look out for we, the people. Instead they lined their democratic coffers with Fannie Mae contributions, for example, instead of serving the interests of the public.
    See the list on the next post.
    As for Sen. McCain's record for Veterans, look here
    http://www.johnmccain.com/Informing/Issues/9cb5d2aa-f237-464e-9cdf-a5ad32771b9f.htm "

    Dilbert wrote on Oct 24, 2008 4:47 PM:

    " I'm allergic to Bee's "

    Hmmm wrote on Oct 23, 2008 7:24 AM:

    " By responsive government are you talking about how McShame voted against VA benefits and wounded warriors? Now how is that responsive. Responsive equals demcrats. Irresponsible equals repubicans. "

    George wrote on Oct 21, 2008 1:10 PM:

    " Gabby rocks! She supports veteran's issues, unlike Bee and McCain. She has been endorsed by the VFW. My whole family, relatives, and friends will be voting for her this election. She is destined to be a great Congresswoman for decades to come! "

    Fat Murphy wrote on Oct 21, 2008 12:51 AM:

    " Mr. Bland, Giffords belongs to the democrat controlled congress with the lowest approval rating ever. Alot of downturns since the democrats took over congress. Why would you want to vote for Giffords in light of the record? "

    Vote Republican for responsive Govt wrote on Oct 20, 2008 7:59 PM:

    " Humpo, here's how scared I am: NOT! Even if Obamanation were to become president and Giffords the Congress woman, our country will STILL survive! But they will be voted out of office at the next opportunity. (But they are not going to be elected!) Vote Republican for responsive Gov't "

    Vote Republican for responsive Govt wrote on Oct 20, 2008 7:48 PM:

    " MORE From Gifford's email newsletter dated 10-20-08:
    Throughout October, four different House Committees - Oversight and Government Reform, Financial Services, Agriculture, and Education & Labor - are holding at least eight hearings. Those hearings are examining regulatory mistakes and financial excesses, the role and responsibility of various agencies, as well as the downturn's impact on hard-working and retired Americans.
    "Financial Services" Committee is the one Barney Frank now controls. HE was supposed to be "watching the chicken coop" but he let the wolves in! "We don't need no stinkin' regulations. We need loans to the poor!" "

    Vote Republican for responsive Govt wrote on Oct 20, 2008 7:41 PM:

    " From Gifford's email newsletter dated 10-20-08: "I share your anger and frustration as well as your desire to get to the bottom of what caused this calamity.... Wall street executives who created this mess must be investigated ...."This is laughable! Getting to the bottom means exposing the Democrat-sponsored Community Reinvestment Act which resulted in loans to people who could not afford them. The blame belongs first with Barney Frank, Chris Dodd, and other Democrats! Wall St didn't force these loans on us, the Democrats did! Tactic: Divert attention from Democrats by blaming the other guy. "

    Humpo wrote on Oct 19, 2008 6:45 PM:

    " ...'because Bill O'Rielly told me so.' Listen Republican, every pompous post you write makes me realize more and more what a frightened lamb you are. The scary thing is that there are enough followers like you eating up the propaganda and believing everything Fox News pushes you that the world is going to get more and more dangerous for generations to come, despite what you may have been told to think. "

    Vote Republican for responsive Govt wrote on Oct 19, 2008 7:33 AM:

    " Humpo, sit down and take notes. Who would be defeated? The Iraqi people would be defeated if we leave too soon without stabilizing the country. Stability, under a democratically elected Iraqi government, is almost achieved. The US would be seen as being defeated if we leave too soon and the terrorists disrupt the hard-fought gains of the past 5 years: schools and hospitals, a working government OF THE PEOPLE, not a dictatorship as under Saddam, etc. The state our country is in? NO attacks on US soil since 2001,
    7 of last 8 years were good economy. "

    Humpo wrote on Oct 18, 2008 1:32 AM:

    " Republican, you say a vote for Giffords would support defeat in Iraq. Who would be defeated? Is the answer "the U.S."? Who would be the victor. The "terrorists"? Or maybe "the axis of evil"? Did you decide at some point that your vote depends solely on who comes up with the most outrageous and unbelievable, albeit creative and comicbook-like propaganda? Are you a 12 year-old boy with "Justice League Comics" stacked neatly on your bedstand? People like you are the reason our country is in the state it is in. "

    Hmmmm wrote on Oct 17, 2008 1:18 PM:

    " It was McSame who rushed to the frontline for government buy out of private industry, then Paulson said they made a mistake. Is this what we can expect with McSame? More failures and an UNRESPONSIVE PRESIDENT. Bush responded alright with more debt and over 4,000 dead troops and 100,000 wounded warriors. Then McSame voted against healthcare for the wounded warriors. That is not responsive that is what we call responsible. The republicans are responsible for the economy under the direction of Bush with the full support of McBush. Bush failed and McBush is an even bigger failure. "

    Vote Republican for responsive wrote on Oct 17, 2008 6:34 AM:

    " Humpo, stay off the radical web sites. Your "facts" are unproven. A vote for GIFFORDS is a vote for LOSERS! A Pelosi clone, she would support DEFEAT in IRAQ and Afghanistan. Giffords is more of the same same SPEND, Spend, spend philosophy, which even Pres Bush did way too much of, thanks to a liberal Democrat Congress. At least Pres Bush had the good sense to give us TAX CUTS.... which will expire under a Democrat-controlled Congress.... which is a TAX INCREASE. Vote Republican for responsive "

    Yea Right wrote on Oct 17, 2008 12:45 AM:

    " Arthor, as a life long Republican, please explain what you mean by "bought the GOP line"? "

    Billy Hill wrote on Oct 16, 2008 11:24 PM:

    " I'm voting for Tim because he's not Gabby Giffords. "

    Giffords voted for Bailout wrote on Oct 16, 2008 10:17 AM:

    " Gifford folded and voted for the bailout. Any congress representative that voted for the bailout measure should be voted out of office! They all have fallen victem to corporate lobbyists. "

    Humpo wrote on Oct 16, 2008 5:38 AM:

    " So, Republican, you're saying bombing and killing hundreds of thousands of innocent children and their family members is ok, just so long as they've actually had a chance to be born...and they aren't United States citizens, of course. "

    Hmmm wrote on Oct 16, 2008 1:44 AM:

    " What does Tim Bee stand for? What kind of policies will he try to get by us? Well if his endorsement by Bush is any indication we are all in trouble. Bee will follow party lines like he did in the State Senate and fall in line with the failed policies of the Bush administration. Thankfully the polls show Giffords with about a 20% lead. "

    Arthur Dent wrote on Oct 15, 2008 6:46 PM:

    " Interesting that the Veterans of Foriegn Wars endorsed Giffords "

    Arthur Dent wrote on Oct 15, 2008 3:56 PM:

    " The VFW has bought the GOP line for decades since before Eisenhower, suddenly they have NOT endorsed McGoo but they have endorsed Giffords "

    Vote Republican for responsive Govt wrote on Oct 15, 2008 7:20 AM:

    " A vote for Giffords is a vote for Pelosi and the DO-NOTHING Congress they are in charge of. "

    Voter wrote on Oct 15, 2008 7:15 AM:

    " Giffords campaign commericals are a bit over the top. Walking down a dusty road with an old sheriff, in her barbie doll western wear outfit.
    Her statement about being the only Rep. married to an active duty service member. She is desperate, especially after flip floping on the bailout bill. "

    Ray wrote on Oct 14, 2008 9:03 AM:

    " When has any astronaut ever been referred to as "a member of the military"? I've have never heard it...that is until Giffords started using the phrase towards her husband...She's trying every angle, isn't she..... "

    Illegal wrote on Oct 13, 2008 7:32 PM:

    " I like Giffords, she says I can belong to a union, and the unions gave contributed a lot of money. "

    Moe Ron wrote on Oct 13, 2008 7:21 PM:

    " I'm voting for her because she's not Tim Bee "

    Independent wrote on Oct 13, 2008 2:32 PM:

    " As much as I would like to vote for a capable woman, I will not vote for Gabby Giffords because she repeatedly has said she supports AMNESTY 12-20 million illegal aliens already in this country. And she continually supports efforts to increase the VISA programs to bring in more legal immigrants. Some things to admire (talent, energy, organization--great staff efforts--and homegrown) but she will only follow Raul Grijalva's vote in WDC. We need an original - vote Tim Bee. Three branches in either party's hands is unwise (remember Republican control?) "

    sierravistan wrote on Oct 13, 2008 10:45 AM:

    " Sorry, but being married to an astronaut doesn't give her a clue about the sacrifices our soldiers are making and our vets have made. Where is she on NCLB? Where is she on illegal immigration? Where is she on helping Ramos and Compean, the border patrol agents who were thrown in jail for doing their jobs? "

    Vote republican for responsive govt wrote on Oct 13, 2008 6:58 AM:

    " Mark C, Democrats currently run Congress, especially the House. It would be better to have more "diversity" of opinions (translation: Republicans) so as to have some CHECKS and BALANCES, especially if Obama should win. "

    Giffords is for Giffords wrote on Oct 12, 2008 6:16 PM:

    " If you believe what Giffords says at election time, you need to read more.
    She isn't against illegal immigration, if fact she thinks that illegals should be able to join a union, of which the unions contributed over $400,000 to her campaign. She talks the talk about supporting the troops, just as McCain does, but the facts speak for themselves. "

    Mark C. wrote on Oct 12, 2008 2:35 PM:

    " I can understand being opposed to a supreme court justice because they aren't willing to outlaw abortion, or even a President, however Giffords or Bee will have zero impact on abortions in this country. She is a fiscal conservative, she does a great job looking out for our soldiers, and she is best suited to looking out for our interests in a Democratic led house. "

    Fat Murphy wrote on Oct 12, 2008 1:37 PM:

    " Married to an active duty military who is an astronaut. How would she know of the sacrifices of the men and women who are fighting? How can she relate to military families? Just abunch more hogwash Bob. "

    Vote republican for responsive govt wrote on Oct 12, 2008 6:20 AM:

    " 40 million DEAD BABIES is all I need to know about the Democrats, including Giffords. Vote republican for responsive gov't. "

Community Videos



Additional recent videos can be viewed here


Use the arrows on each side of the player to for the next/previous video

Lastest U.S. Videos


In Tomorrow's Herald


WHAT’S YOUR OPINION? A special day of On Your Mind comments in the Herald/Review.

Subscribe Today!

Photo Galleries

Contact Us


Staff Directory

Advertisement




Reader Poll



Calendar

Upcoming Events:

Faith and Spirituality