News : Dying man’s family struggles with unplanned funeral expenses : Sierra Vista, AZ

Today's Weather


Click for Sierra Vista, Arizona Forecast


Dying man’s family struggles with unplanned funeral expenses

BY LAURA ORY
HERALD/REVIEW
Published/Last Modified on Saturday, Jul 14, 2007 - 05:15:58 am MST

HUACHUCA CITY — Nelson Alexander was 46 and only expected to live for another week.

He didn’t have many wishes before he died, but he knew he wanted to be buried as close as possible to his brother at Cochise Memorial Gardens.

And his wife, Kay, knew she would do all she could to make that happen. But she didn’t have the money to pay for it.

Throughout the last week he was told he would live — and the four days more he survived — family and friends at his home in Huachuca City provided him with as much comfort as they could.


An unresponsive Nelson Alexander is comforted by his wife, Kay, while daughter-in-law Jessica Martin looks on Wednesday in his Huachuca City home. The 46-year-old Alexander died Thursday afternoon. (Mark Levy-Herald/Review)


Diabetes and high blood pressure wrecked his body for years until Nelson became terminally ill three and half years ago. He also needed heart and kidney transplants, but was ineligible because of his other health problems. He battled vascular disease, neuropathy, was going blind and had dialysis treatments three times a week. He couldn’t work, and Kay also stopped working to take care of him.

The Alexanders and three of their five children barely covered all their expenses month-to-month with the $1,200 they received from his disability.

But when Nelson recently developed a staph infection and needed a foot amputated, he chose to stop his medical care on July 1.

“It’s the hardest decision I’ve ever had to support,” Kay said Monday. “But it’s about his wishes. No more suffering.”

As Kay Alexander began to look into the costs of burying her husband, the arrangments totaled $7,500 in cemetery and funeral costs.

“We’ve had three and a half years to talk about his wishes, but we forgot to talk about the financial part of it,” she said.

It’s not uncommon problem, said Ron Maynez, funeral director at Hatfield Funeral Home, 830 S. Highway 92.

“Illness can drain an estate,” he said.

It’s important for families to look at funeral costs realistically, he said.

“Everybody wants the Cadillac but wants to pay Honda prices,” Maynez said.

Some families may have funeral benefits through life insurance, their church or the military. Kay said she would probably receive about $250 from Social Security to help cover the costs.

Cochise County provides indigent cremation or burial at Calvary Cemetary in Douglas for some low-income families, Maynez said. That wasn’t an option for the Alexanders, because they wanted to provide Nelson’s wish of being buried at Cochise Memorial Gardens.

By state law, each county must provide indigent burial services for families who qualify, said Rudy Thomas, director for the state Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers.

Information about Cochise County’s program was sought by the Herald/Review from Karla Jensen, the county’s public information officer.

Consumers should also be aware that funeral homes are required to present a general price list before discussing funeral arrangements. Casket and outer burial container price lists must also be presented to customers.

Although the state can’t regulate prices, funeral homes can’t change the prices shown to consumers, Thomas said.

Most funeral homes require funeral expenses to be paid in full before the funeral, but families can pre-pay and pre-plan funerals through funeral trusts and insurance-funded funeral plans.

In some cases, pre-paying can also lock in today’s price, he said.

The average funeral cost is $5,000, though cremations start at about $1,200, he said.

“More and more families are looking to cremation,” he said. Last year about 60 percent of Arizonans chose cremation over conventional burial or deportation, according to the state Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers.

Paul Parker, director of the Bisbee and San Pedro Funeral Homes, said he advises families to be practical in their choices after a funeral.

“If you don’t prepare, it’s a difficult state to be in,” Parker said. “I’d like to help people, but I’m running a business, too.”

Kay said it’s a difficult situation for families to be in, as well.

“Funeral homes kind of have you over a barrel. You can’t do it on your own,” she said.

It’s a common misconception that families must make arrangments with a funeral home, said Josh Slocum, executive director of the Funeral Consumer Alliance, a nonprofit educational and advocate organization for funeral consumers.

“Most people spend too much on funerals,” Slocum said.

Janet Jacobs, a volunteer for the Southern Arizona Funeral Consumer Alliance, said she payed too much for her husband’s funeral.

“I could have put my kids through college with the money I spent on the funeral in 1973,” she said.

Holding a memorial at home and preparing the death certificate themselves are some ways people can reduce funeral costs in a way that is meaningful and personal, Slocum said.

In most cases, embalming is not required in Arizona if the body remains refrigerated or is buried within 24 hours, unless the body will be viewed 24 hours after death, Thomas said.

That’s about $500 you would save,” Jacobs said.

A casket isn’t required either, though a “minimum container,” similar to cardboard is required, Thomas said.

But if a casket is desired, it doesn’t have to be purchased at a funeral home, Jacobs said.

“If you make your own casket out of plywood, they have to accept it,” Jacobs said.

Customers should be aware that they may face unexpected costs as well when planning a funeral, Thomas said. For example, most cemeteries require an outer vault for the casket, usually to prevent the ground from collapsing on a gravesite.

The Southern Arizona chapter also provides its members with discounted burial and cremation services from $520 to $1,020 at a Tucson funeral home, Jacobs said.

People should know they have options for an affordable funeral, she said.

“And you don’t have to take out a second mortgage,” Jacobs said.

For now, Kay Alexander said she will ask for donations from the community to help cover the funeral costs.

“We’re not trying to be fancy,” she said. “We’re just trying to give him his basic wishes.”

She began making funeral arrangments with Hatfield Funeral Home after Nelson died Thursday. A viewing and funeral will follow later this week, she said.

She hopes that people in the community remember him from his 15 years of work at the Army and Airforce Exchange Service for his years as a little league baseball, softball and basketball coach in Sierra Vista, Fort Huachua and Huachuca City.

“This is not a ‘poor me’ story,” Kay said. “We’ve not planned properly. We don’t have the money to bury him, but he was a good man and coached for many years, and I’m hoping people remember that.”

He was a hard worker who loved his family, she said.

“Even if he had to work two or three jobs, he always provided for us.”

Kay said she hopes that other families can learn from hers.

“Not many 40-year-olds think, ‘I might die in the next 10 years,’ but they need to think about it,” she said.

A benefit account has been created by the Alexander family under Nelson Alexander’s name at Wells Fargo for donations for his funeral.

herald/review reporter Laura Ory can be reached at 515-4683 or by e-mail at svhnews@transedge.com.



Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments appear once they are approved. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   





    PJP wrote on Jul 24, 2007 5:46 PM:

    " I read this article with tears in my eyes. Apparantly some people have never sinned and are more than willing to be the first to throw a stone. We have all done things that we are not proud of. My heart goes out to this brave family. Watching your father die is a horrible thing for anyone especially young adults, and small children. God Bless the Alexander family and please keep them in your prayers. "

    Sad wrote on Jul 24, 2007 4:20 PM:

    " It is so sad that people can attack and judge a family of the same community. How perfect are your families? It is even sadder when it comes from people who have known them, whether well or not. What happened to love thy neighbor? Where is any compassion? Nobody is perfect,they just lost a loved one, and the last thing they should be getting from their neighbors is criticism and just plain meanness.So don’t help them out, but you should keep your negative thoughts to yourself. I will be praying for this family "

    WWJD wrote on Jul 21, 2007 6:28 AM:

    " Enough now people, where is your compassion? Remember ''What would Jesus Do?" Let the family be and let Nelson rest in peace. My condolences to the Alexander family. Our prayers are with you during this difficult time. WWJD "

    upset wrote on Jul 19, 2007 11:42 PM:

    " I didnt know it was our job to judge. Everyone is judging a man that is no longer with us as if we are all perfect. Everyone makes mistakes in life that doesnt mean you should not have the right to rest in peace. The family is going through a verry hard time and they dont need all the negative coments from people. KEEP THE NEGATIVE COMENTS TO YOURSELF! "

    RRR wrote on Jul 19, 2007 9:04 PM:

    " To Shocked: If a family doesn't want to be "publicly humiliated", perhaps they should have deny the interview. Chances are, someone will know you. Chances are, someone will have a negative opinion. He had been terminally ill for 3 years, I think he should have prepared for his funeral. Kay wanted her story to go public to include asking for donations from the community. Did she really expect 100% sympathy and compassion from the readers? "

    shocked wrote on Jul 19, 2007 12:07 PM:

    " Isn’t a news article on a limited subject matter? This story seemed simply addressing the financial hardship death can place on the surviving family. The author wasn’t writing a full biography of, nor making a judgment of these people’s lives. It’s sad that some people can’t let their anger go and have to publicly humiliate this family. All families are flawed in some ways, and even the most imperfect of us have real problems in life. Hopefully I never have the misfortune to have an article about me printed in this community. "

    James M. wrote on Jul 18, 2007 9:43 PM:

    " After the passing of my first wife in 2001, I made arrangements with Hatfields to pre-pay for my burial/cremation. This took a lot of the burden off of my second wife. I also checked into the use of my body for science. This could also be a way for Kay to reduce funeral expenses, just do not go to the University of Arizona, go to other 'companies' to see what they can do. Also, pre-paying is a way to see what you want done after you are gone is what happens. "

    Come on... wrote on Jul 18, 2007 3:48 PM:

    " I totally agree with HC neighbor. THey are asking the community to help them out once again. Are we guaranteed that the money donated will be specifically for funeral arrangements/burial? I don't trust donating money that Kay may use for other things. This aricle does not paint an accurate picture of how they lived their lives, especially during the last 5 years. I feel this article is very inaccurate...tell the whole story, not just a paint by numbers story... "

    lc wrote on Jul 18, 2007 3:38 PM:

    " everyone is commiting on me but not the rest of the people that agree with me !!! if u were to know this fam than u would understand that they could have been prepared for this but they chose not to ... kay quit working well over 10 years ago.. u people need to understand that they need to strive for thim selfs we all have too ... its part of life "

    Beautifully Depressed wrote on Jul 17, 2007 9:46 PM:

    " LC: Wow! Are you always so judgemental? I do not know this family, but I feel for the situation they are in. Losing a loved one is horrible, and they have the added stress of inadequate finances. You choose to comment on their personal lives of which you probably know very little. You are very cold hearted and you should be ashamed of yourself. Bottom line...grow up and go look in the mirror. Your ignorant comments will come back to haunt you in the form of karma. "

    MC wrote on Jul 17, 2007 9:33 PM:

    " Shame on all of you who are criticizing this family who is grieving over the loss of their husband, father, and friend! How dare you persecute a man who is dead! This was a hard working man, and was obviously well respected by a lot of people. Do not pass judgement on this family, but especially on the wife! If my husband became incapacitated tomorrow and I could not afford to pay a private caretaker for him 24/7 you better bet I would quit my job too! The point is that this man deserves to rest in peace! "

    HC neighbor wrote on Jul 17, 2007 2:26 PM:

    " It's never a easy thing to accept when a family member passes away, but to say this family has made a few poor choices is a total understatement. I don't believe this article paints a accurate picture! Unfortunately these people made nothing but poor life choices. It's a shame that they are asking the community to bail them out once again. Eventually you have to accept some responsibility for the things you've done throughout your life. Karma is a powerful thing. "

    mjo wrote on Jul 17, 2007 9:41 AM:

    " Are the expenses also including his wish to be buried @ Cochise Mem Gdns? Did he bother to find out how much HIS funeral would cost before he died? Was he aware that his wife has to deal with all this? I would tell my kids to just cremate me, $1200 versus $7500? Gee, my family survives on only $1200 a month. He may have contributed to society but I think his dying wishes are pretty selfish, and his wife needs to prioritze, dead man or kids who have to eat? "

    jack wrote on Jul 17, 2007 8:06 AM:

    " We don't like to think about it, but we are ALL going to die. My take on this article is that we ALL should plan and prepare for the way we want to go. There are a number of options available and we should prepare for the one that suits our needs. "

    desert mom wrote on Jul 17, 2007 6:19 AM:

    " LC, I think you are being quite heartless towards this family. Maybe they did not always make good choices, (we all fall under this category) but now they are greiving over the loss of their father/husband. None of us are perfect, but only Forgiven by a loving God. Instead of attacking them, why not show a little compassion and pray for them?!! This Christian will. "

    AzLuna wrote on Jul 16, 2007 10:20 PM:

    " I can't believe that this mans death has caused such chaos. You know "this doesn't add up", your comment, "I'm sorry, but if you haven't prepared adequately, sometimes you just don't get to have what you want. It's called sacrifice.", sounds exactly what my boss would say. Just like what I HEARD my boss say about a very dear friend of mine, who she tells people that she fired, when in fact they quit. I'll say it again, your comment was just heartless and cold. "

    FRIEND wrote on Jul 16, 2007 9:25 PM:

    " LC I HAVE KNOWN THIS FAMILY FOR 30 YEARS OR MORE I KNOW THAT WHEN I WAS STRUGGLING IN SCHOOL NELSON WAS THERE FOR ME AND REGAURDLESS OF WHAT YOU MAY THINK OF THIS FAMILY THEY ARE CARING PEOPLE AND NELSON GAVE ALOT OF HIMSELF FOR ALOT OF KIDS. I HAVE ALSO WORKED AS A DIALYSIS TECH. AND SOME PEOPLE HAVE DIFFERENT PROBLEMS ASSOCIATED WITH KIDNEY FAILURE.IT IS NOT UNCOMMON FOR PEOPLE TO LIVE LONG AND NORMAL LIVES BUT IT IS ALSO NOT UNCOMMON FOR PEOPLE TO SUFFER WITH THIS.APPARENTLY YOU HAVE A PERSONAL PROBLEM WITH KAY. "

    LC wrote on Jul 16, 2007 8:34 AM:

    " THIS IS FOR 'FRIEND' I DO KNOW THIS FAMILY VERY WELL AND I DO KNOW WHAT IT IS LIKE TO HAVE DIABETES AND KIDNEY FALUER A CLOSE FAMILY MEMBER HAS IT ALSO BUT THIS PERSON TAKES CARE OF THEM SELFS AND IS STILL IN GOOD CONDITION !!! KAY DID NOT STOP WORKING FOR NELSON SHE JUST HASNT WORKED FOR YEARS . WHAT KIND OF PEOPLE WERE THEY REALLY ??? "

    Daughter wrote on Jul 15, 2007 1:25 PM:

    " For you information i do work matter of fact i have three jobs and i go to school and there is no one else in the house that can work what you think my little sister victoria being only 11 years old should go out and get a job thats not fair if you dont have any thing good to say dont talk at all because my family is going through a hard time and your facts are false!!!!!!!!! "

    Family wrote on Jul 15, 2007 1:18 PM:

    " Just a few facts that should be known Kay is sick as well and is unable to work, oldest three children do not reside at home and can barely make it on thier own, Just turn seventeen year old attends college and works. Family just started to pay life insurance and not eligible for coverage yet. "

    Lisa Carlson wrote on Jul 15, 2007 12:25 PM:

    " It's too bad that families think they have to have the expensive funeral that funeral directors want to sell. If the family can scrape together the money for the plot, the vault, and the opening and closing (maybe $2,000?), they could have planned the rest themselves without a funeral director, just as our great-grandparents did. The do-it-yourself funeral is the most loving way to say goodbye, but many don't know they have this option. Why aren't clergy doing more to inform the public? "

    Jo wrote on Jul 15, 2007 12:20 PM:

    " I think what makes this story hit wrong is the way the information about the funeral costs is presented. Instead of simply showing how much it actually costs to bury a loved one & how to plan for those expenses, the story focuses on how to cut costs. The Alexander family's problem isn't that they want an elaborate ceremony & burial, just that they didn't plan a way to save for the basics they find appropriate. It changes the tone of the family's situation. I hope it doesn't cause people to misinterpret their need. My condolences for your loss. "

    Oh really? wrote on Jul 15, 2007 9:39 AM:

    " He chose to volunteer, he chose those sacrifices. I think the whole story of what Kay and Nelson have done should be posted...not just the story of ill-preparedness. Does the author/interviewer do ANY type of research before doing ths story or does she just eat the words falling from other's mouths? Will the money be used solely for the purpose of Nelson's funeral costs? Nelson was a great man who strived to achieve greatness for himself and others. The world has lost a shining star... "

    FRIEND wrote on Jul 15, 2007 7:59 AM:

    " LC YOU HAVE NO CLUE AS TO WHAT IS GOING ON HERE. YOU NEED TO REREAD THE STORY. YOU SHOULD RESEARCH WHAT LIFE IS LIKE FOR PEOPLE WITH DIABETES, AND NO KIDNEYS. KAY DID WORK. SHE WORKED HER BUTT OFF CARING FOR HER HUSBAND. THE CHILDREN DID CONTRIBUTE IN MORE WAYS THAN ONE. GET SOME FACTS BEFORE YOU DECIDE TO SPEAK NEXT TIME.. "

    Connie wrote on Jul 15, 2007 2:03 AM:

    " This family is grieving and watching someone you love suffer the way he did is something I wish on no one. But after my father died and the funeral home made over $10,000 on his death, I'm determined to go as cheaply as possible when I die. Burry me in a plain pine box, no bother with a viewing and that way I can save my kin thousands of dollars. I don't want a lavish funeral because I'll be DEAD!!! The money should go to my family for more important things "

    Hereford wrote on Jul 14, 2007 10:34 PM:

    " I am very sorry for your loss. Mr. Alexander was a good man and brought a lot of good to our community. Your family will be in my prayers. "

    One who really knows... wrote on Jul 14, 2007 10:01 PM:

    " Many have missed the point of this article all together. This is not a charity case. How many of us 40ish year olds have planned for our deaths? So if one of us has decided to from this article to plan ahead then we have benefitted from this family's story. Thanks KAY!!! "

    humm. . . wrote on Jul 14, 2007 9:39 PM:

    " for all of those that knew the family would agree with "this doesnt add up" and "lc". i agree with them 100% "

    A Community Neighbor wrote on Jul 14, 2007 8:15 PM:

    " Our condolences to a neighbor in this community who gave of his time to coach little league. "

    Donna Hunt wrote on Jul 14, 2007 7:39 PM:

    " I find it so hard to believe that anyone would attack a grieving family. The reality is that a great many families struggle to get by on fixed incomes, but that isn't really the issue here. Kay had the courage to step forward and admit they messed up with their finances, and now they need help. Everybody has made a mistake or two in their lives. I wish I could afford to help them, and I hope they find the money to pay for his burial. "

    Daniel grissom.. wrote on Jul 14, 2007 7:34 PM:

    " "Honorable Man", NelsonAlexander was is a good man to his family also to the chidren to the community which called him coach.All families and indvisuals fall short from perfection except for one man JESUS. Though this man Nelson through all the pain from health issues,He took care of his family.All of his hard work and the diabets and diyalis,and knowing his kids could give him a kidney the risk to him to high so he made the ultimate sacrfice and choice to let GOD take him home and in MY HEART NELSON IS HONORABLE.NO MORE PAIN.1 "

    the oldest daughter of Nelson Alexander wrote on Jul 14, 2007 5:35 PM:

    " My Dad did many great things for childeren from huachuca City to Bisbee Az. He not only coached but he took kids in he would provide a home and included many kids as his own. Nobody is asking for a pity trip or hand outs but we all expected my Dad to live many more years. I hope through our family that another will not be in the same postion we are in. My dad does not have just five childeren he has about 100 kids that love him and will never forget him. This is far from asking PITY "

    sad at the finger pointers wrote on Jul 14, 2007 3:28 PM:

    " To "This doesn't add up" Why couldn't you just leave well enough alone? Ever heard the phrase "think it but don't speak it?" This family is obviously going through a rough patch, and maybe they didn't plan well. You certainly don't have to donate to the family if your heart isn't in it. From the article it sounded like the deceased DID sacrifice.... Have any of your children played sports? This man coached, I'd call that a sacrifice! "

    Cathy wrote on Jul 14, 2007 1:40 PM:

    " Shame on writer "This doesn't add up"... Sometimes it is better to bite your tongue than say what you think. You sound very heartless and cold and I hope you never find yourself in the same shoes as this family, or on second thought maybe you should walk a mile in their shoes. It might make you more compassionate. "

    LC wrote on Jul 14, 2007 1:09 PM:

    " WELL IT IS SAD AND HARD TO KNOW THAT YOU ARE GOING TO DIE AND WHEN ... BUT AT THE SAME TIME KNOWING THAT YOU ARE SICK AND YOU NEED TO TAKE CARE OF YOUR SELF TAKES A BIG TOLL IN THIS SITUATION !!! HE DID HAVE 2 OLDER KIDS THAT WERE ABLE TO WORK AND DIDNT AND WANTED TO LIVE OFF OF MOMMY AND DADDY AND KAY COULD HAVE WORKED !!! I BELIVE THAT THE COMUNITY IN THIS SITUATION SHOULD NOT HELP AND LET THEM STRIVE FOR THEM SELFS .. THIS ISNT A CHARITY CASE ITS THE FACTS ... "

    He was my coach wrote on Jul 14, 2007 10:31 AM:

    " There are not "four able bodied" people in the home.Kay quit her job to care for Nelson (as he required 24 hour care). This family is not looking for pity and admit to being ill prepared.They agreed to do this story with the intention of preventing other families from being in this predicament.The 3 children that do live with them are minors, the oldest 2 do work to help provide. One of the daughters graduated high school early, attends Cochise College and works 3 jobs. Sacrifice may also be 15 years of Nelson volunteering his time to the children ofthiscommunity. "

    AzLuna wrote on Jul 14, 2007 10:26 AM:

    " Apparently "this doesn't add up" doesn't understand what it's like to live on a fixed income. I'm sure it's not their fault that more of them couldn't work to support the family. I'm even more sure that Mr. Nelson would not want to spend his last days in some crappy nursing home. He was right where he belonged. With his family by his side. So for you to say that more people could have worked is just heartless. Get a clue! My condolences to the family. "

    Rick wrote on Jul 14, 2007 10:09 AM:

    " Nelson was a good man, with a great sense of Humor. "

    This doesn't add up wrote on Jul 14, 2007 8:00 AM:

    " Do I understand this correctly? There are four able-bodied people in this household and between them, they are attempting to survive on 1200.00 a month? Surely four people can manage to earn more than that? I don't understand why they are living on the disability rather than on income from jobs. The reporter must have botched that up which is unfortunate for the family. Sad story, none-the-less. And I'm sorry, but if you haven't prepared adequately, sometimes you just don't get to have what you want. It's called sacrifice. "

Community Videos



Additional recent videos can be viewed here


Use the arrows on each side of the player to for the next/previous video

Lastest U.S. Videos


In Tomorrow's Herald


Striking Gould

Subscribe Today!

Photo Galleries

Contact Us


Staff Directory

Advertisement




Reader Poll



Calendar

Upcoming Events:

Faith and Spirituality